Get Your Free Case Valuation

Negligence Waivers and How They Affect Your Medical Malpractice Claim

Negligence Waivers and How They Affect Your Medical Malpractice Claim
Insights Med. Malpractice Oct. 19 3 min read

Most of us are familiar with the stack of medical documents handed to us at the doctor’s office. Many people start filling in details and signing papers just to get them submitted without knowing what they actually mean. 

However, if you then experience an issue that could be medical malpractice, all those documents start to feel much more important. That said, can you sue for malpractice if you have already signed a waiver? 

Negligence Waivers

Medical malpractice waivers are not enforceable when they involve professional negligence that goes against public policy.

These waivers typically have you agree that you understand the risks associated with the medical procedure you are undergoing and that you will not hold the doctor responsible for any losses that could result. In other words, you are releasing them of liability. 

When are negligence waivers enforceable, and when are they not?

Waiving your legal right to sue in a medical malpractice claim before receiving medical care goes against public policy, and as a result, most waivers are not enforceable.

The potential of a medical malpractice claim ensures that medical professionals deliver the best care. After all, it doesn’t make sense that just because you signed a waiver, they no longer have to take precautions and care when giving treatment. Many patients sign these waivers because they feel they won’t be able to get the medical care needed if they don’t. 

However, just because you can claim negligence doesn’t guarantee you will succeed—you must still prove all elements of medical malpractice occurred. 

It can be difficult to argue against a waiver that states you gave informed consent or that you knew the risks before you received the treatment. But it is possible that the medical professional did not take the proper steps to provide adequate informed consent. Many medical malpractice claims involve a lack of informed consent. 

Case Law that Prohibits Medical Malpractice Waivers

  1. Tunkl v. Regents of University of California, 383 P.2d 441 (Cal. 1963). A hospital may not require a release of liability before treatment. An agreement between a hospital and an entering patient affects the public interest and that, in consequence, it must be invalid under Civil Code section 1668.
  2. Cudnik v. William Beaumont Hospital, 207 Mich. App. 378 (Mich. Ct. App. 1994). An exculpatory agreement signed before the patient receives medical treatment is invalid as it is against public policy.
  3. Ash v. NY Univ. Dental Center, 564 N.Y.S.2d 308 (1990). Exculpatory agreements are against public policy, and invalidating them protects the welfare of its citizens to ensure better medical care.
  4. Smith v. Hospital Authority, 287 S.E.2d 99 (Ga. Ct. App. 1981). Agreements may not relieve the practitioner from the duty to exercise reasonable care and skill in the performance of his practice. The signing of these agreements as a complete defense against negligence is unenforceable.

Final Thoughts

If all of this seems confusing or if you still aren’t sure if the waiver you signed will keep you from making a medical malpractice claim, get the help of an experienced medical malpractice attorney. Improper care or treatment should not be allowed, and you deserve compensation if a medical practitioner acted in a negligent manner that has caused you additional harm.

What's your case worth?

Answer a few questions to see what your case could be worth and get an instant case value.

Find Out What Your Case is Worth

Answer a few questions to see what your case could be worth and get an instant case value.

Get Your Case Value Estimate

Share This Site With a Friend

If you know someone who would find this site helpful, share it with them via social media or email or by copying the link below.

Find Out What Your Case is Worth

Answer a few questions to see what your case could be worth and get an instant case value.

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

Unfortunately, because you were found at fault, your case will most likely be overturned by a judge, and therefore, a case value cannot be calculated.

Unfortunately, because your incident happened 12+ months ago, your case falls outside the statute of limitations for your state, and therefore, a case value cannot be calculated.

Unfortunately, because you were found at fault and your incident happened 12+ months ago, your case will most likely be overturned by a judge, and therefore, a case value cannot be calculated.

Uh oh: It looks like you didn't provide us with enough details to calculate a case value.

Legal Disclaimer

The information we provide does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. No attorney-client relationship is established when you submit the form, and you are under no obligation to retain an attorney who may contact you through this service. All claim reviews will be performed by a third-party attorney.